Book Review: The Other Girl by Emily Barr

The Other Girl by Emily Barr
Published: May 9th 2025 by Penguin
Rating: ★★★★ (4 stars)
Genres: Young Adult // Contemporary, Thriller
Quick Thoughts: Continually gripping, suspensefully captivating from start to finish. Having two unreliable narrators was quite the tantalising experience, and it really sets up the cycle of keeping the drama unravelling all the way through . . . it feels authentically fresh in the mystery genre.
I was gifted this book via the Publisher/PR. There was no obligation to post/give this book a certain rating. All views are my own. I remain entirely impartial.
Join The Conversation
Reader Information: View Content Warnings.
TW: this book contains references of drunk driving, scams, fraud, stalking, injury, family issues, parental issues and death. 14+.
Strangers on a train
Switching places
Who are you, really?
Unexpected Love
About This Book:
Stealing someone’s life looks impossible too, but hey. Watch me.
Two girls meet on a train journey.
One of them – privileged, chaotic – is heading to an exclusive Swiss rehab centre following months of partying and living wildly.
The other – who couldn’t be more different – is down to her last penny, running away.
When they get off the train they are both pretending to be the other. Just for a short period, of course. Just until the rehab stint is over . . .
From the bestselling author of The One Memory of Flora Banks and Ghosted, The Other Girl is a page-turning new YA thriller for fans of Holly Jackson and Ravena Guron.
First Thoughts
I was so intrigued by this book right from the get-go. When I was offered the chance to read it early (thank you, Nina!) I knew I’d welcome a YA Thriller into my life with open arms. I’m new to Emily’s novels but have seen them floating around the YA space for some time, so I wanted to know if I loved The Other Girl and would then pick up her other novels!
My Review
Tabbi doesn’t want to be heading to rehab. Sure, it’s in the Swiss mountains and, because of her privileged upbringing (though very estranged) and family wealth, would be more of a luxurious stay than your standard rehab. The sights might be nice. But, still—Tabbi doesn’t want to go. She’s not ready to face the things she’s done back home that led to this solution. Chaotic and brazen, she befriends another girl on the train heading to her destination. Ruby is very different to Tabbi. Heading to unknown locations to travel and explore sounds much nicer to Tabbi than where she’s headed, whereas Ruby thinks being Tabbi, heading to guaranteed luxury, sounds much more inviting than her plans. So, in a slightly unorthodox and underhanded way, Tabbi suggests that maybe they should swap places. Ruby could become her, and she should become normal-Ruby.
But Ruby is far from normal. Tabbi doesn’t realise this at first, of course, and long after they have altered their appearances by cutting their hair and swapping perfumes and outfits, even passports. Becoming Ruby for Tabbi is easy, for a while, although she wasn’t prepared for tent-living and making a small paycheck to get by until the girls swap back places at their set time. Only, when a boy finds Tabbi, using the name Ruby, she’s dumbfounded at the things her swapped-persona has done. No wonder she willingly went along—was this even an idea of Tabbi’s? Who really is the girl whose identity she has taken on? Through searches, confessions and snippets of the girl’s lives, the truth of Ruby’s past and Tabbi’s secret comes back to haunt them both—each paying for the pain of one another. But at the end of it, are they both willing to give up the new lives they created as each other, or will the alluring pull of a fresh start be the end of their old selves?
Overall, The Other Girl was continually gripping, suspensefully captivating from start to finish. Having two unreliable narrators was quite the tantalising experience, and it really sets up the cycle of keeping the drama unravelling all the way through which definitely made me want to keep turning pages late into the night. I adored the character development in this. Tabbi stood out for me, and I love that the book weighs into the consequences and accountability of owning our pasts. Emily’s writing paints an action-packed escapade through Europe, complicated lies and fabricated bygones. There is so much to love in this story, and it feels authentically fresh in the mystery genre. I think this will even appeal to book lovers who aren’t usually YA readers, too. I’m so excited to read more from Emily—an all-round amazing book!
RATING:

Let me know your thoughts in the comments or via social media to keep the conversation going.
Happy Reading!






